Wine, bourbon, & good company in the heart of downtown Bucyrus.


Your new favorite place to unwind.

Hidden Gem is a locally owned wine and bourbon bar in downtown Bucyrus created for one simple reason: to give people a comfortable place to gather. Come in for a glass of wine after work, discover a new bourbon, meet friends for the evening or settle in on the patio when the weather is right. Whether you know exactly what you like or want to try something new, you’ll find a relaxed place to enjoy it.

Owners Tommy and Lori Starner are usually close by, ready to pour a favorite, help you find something new or simply catch up.

  • Wine by the Glass & Bottle

  • Indoor & Outdoor Seating

  • Small Plates & Shareables

DRINK

SOMETHING

GOOD

Wine, Slushies, Bourbon, Beer, Craft Beer, Limited Cocktails, Seltzers

Whether you already know exactly what you like or want to try something new, there’s plenty to explore behind the bar. Enjoy wine by the glass or bottle, a thoughtfully selected bourbon and spirits collection, seasonal drinks and favorites made for sipping.

And when something catches your eye on the shelf, select bottles are available to take home, too.

SOMETHING TO

GO WITH IT

A little different every time.

Part of the fun at Hidden Gem is seeing what’s on the menu.

Our food offerings rotate, giving us the freedom to serve a curated selection of small plates, shareable bites and seasonal favorites that pair naturally with what’s being poured.

Come hungry for a snack, order something for the table or make an evening of it.

There’s always room for another friend.
Come find your seat at Hidden Gem.

219 S. Sandusky Avenue | Downtown Bucyrus, Ohio

Get Directions

We’re currently in our soft opening phase! For current hours and updates, visit us on Facebook.

Meet the owners

Rooted in Bucyrus. Invested in its future.

For Bucyrus natives Tommy and Lori Starner, Hidden Gem is about more than opening a business. It’s another way to invest in the community they’ve long called home.

Both are deeply connected to Bucyrus through their work, local involvement and relationships throughout the community. They wanted Hidden Gem to feel like the kind of place locals could return to again and again — while also making visitors feel welcome from the moment they walk in.

That same spirit carries into the atmosphere they hope to create: relaxed, friendly and personal. You’ll often find Tommy or Lori there themselves, pouring a glass, talking with guests and helping make Hidden Gem feel less like a stop along the way and more like a place you’ve been coming to for years.